CSI: NY Discussion Points for Episode “Hostage”

May 25, 2008 by Jonathan  

csiny-discuss-header.jpg

Just as in the other two CSI franchise season finales, CSI: NY delivered a killer cliffhanger, loaded with questions. At least in CSI: NY, none of the best loved characters died.

  • Who is Douglas Anderson, or “Joe”, or whatever his name really is?
  • Is the gunman really operating under duress? Is someone really forcing him to do this? The ending tried to lead us to conclude that that was a lie. Was it?
  • Will we find out that the bank manager was in on it, somehow? That’s a stretch, perhaps, but the writers really led us through some weird twists, up to this point.
  • Where are the real (or other) bad guys?
  • Is it possible that Douglas really is being forced, and that he acted in the end just to try to make it all work out?
  • Is Douglas the actual mastermind, and he’s just that deranged an genius? That’s a weird lot to go through, as a ruse, isn’t it?

CSI: NY Discussion Points - 4.20 Taxi

May 14, 2008 by Jonathan  

csiny-discuss-header.jpg

What did you think of CSI: New York episode Taxi? It was very fast paced and exciting, that’s for sure.

  • Did some of the city shots and action remind anyone else of the film Summer of Sam? I thought it sometimes went beyond the superficial, obvious “serial killer in New York City” connection between the show and the movie.
  • Last week, magnets used only at one cab company. This week, motor oil used at only one cab company. When you commit a crime, I guess, make sure you don’t work somewhere that is the only place that uses some obvious technique or product.
  • Those vigilantes make me so angry.
  • Any other computer/IT people concerned by the way Lindsay said she was going to use “Visual Basic” to create a GUI interface to track the IP address?
  • Reed had lost a lot of blood. They definitely made that extreme, considering they didn’t kill him off. But then, maybe it’s not as uncommon to survive that kind of trauma, as I had thought.

CSI: Miami Discussion - 6.20 Down to the Wire

May 12, 2008 by Jonathan  

CSI: Miami Discussion.

I enjoyed this episode, but it kept me thinking more than CSI: Miami usually does. This one was less about the scenery, and maybe less about Horatio’s sass.

  • More than usual, everybody looked like a suspect.
  • That Rossi found it awfully simple to pull a few strings with the state attorney’s office. Is that realistic?
  • That Rossi seems to have fingers in everybody’s food. How is that? It’s almost like all the futuristic gadgetry that Miami CSI seems to have easy access to.
  • Were you watching for the potential cast loss for the week?
  • Don’t worry. Next week, they’re going to try to kill off everyone.
  • Did you follow the dedicated phone line explanation?
  • Did you buy the way that Rossi bought Decker? Maybe there was just that much cash involved. They didn’t talk about that so much.

CSI: Vegas Discussion - Episode 8.16 Two and a Half Deaths

May 11, 2008 by Jonathan  

CSI: Vegas Discussion

If you’re still thinking about this week’s episode of CSI: Vegas, feel free to leave a comment with your opinions, comments, suggestions, etc. Here are a few points to get you started.

  • Funny? I liked some of the funny dialog, but parts left me flat.
  • I watched that explanation of what happened to Natasha a few times to figure out what exactly happened. I’m still not 100% satisfied with the explanation, nor with the video.
  • They didn’t go back to Natasha’s death, so much, either?
  • Did you watch the CSI episode of Two and a Half Men? I thought that was hysterical.

CSI: Miami Discussion - Episode 6.19 Rock and a Hard Place

May 11, 2008 by Jonathan  

CSI: Miami Discussion.

If you’re still thinking about this week’s episode of CSI: Vegas, feel free to leave a comment with your opinions, comments, suggestions, etc. Here are a few points to get you started.

  • The rock only found in one nursery reminds me of Grissom’s figuring out where George was buried on CSI: Vegas by the fire ants in the video. Are nurseries a common element in real life?
  • I was screaming at Brian not to run. Well, inside my head, I was.
  • I was screaming at Brian “Why did you pull the knife out?
  • Between X-Files, Supernatural, and this episode, I don’t know what to say about those few megalomaniacal FBI agents that are ruining it for the rest of them.
  • Speaking of which, that obsession with this one guy is over the top.
  • That Alexx. She was my favorite CSI: Miami character. I really like Warrick, too. Oh, man!

What are your thoughts on episode 6.19 Rock and a Hard Place?

CSI: New York Discussion - 4.19 Personal Foul

May 7, 2008 by Jonathan  

csiny-discuss-header.jpg

Tonight’s episode Personal Foul was classic intense CSI. We had some interesting twists, but no finishing touches.

  • Was I the only one that thought that Lindsay was going to get into the Killer Cab?
  • Paula lost an awful lot of weight, amazingly, not to enjoy the rest of her life, but to get revenge. Crazy much? Discuss.
  • What famous serial killer does the Cabbie Killer most resemble?
  • How will they find the new suspect –John Doe? Another vague and loose dead-end?
  • How much more of this recurring tale, with its first season origins, can Mac take?
  • Mac now has to find Reed. Assuming they rescue him, how will the relationship dynamic change? This is heavy stuff.
  • First Mac has the phone call with a victim’s widow. Now, Reed is taken. How much closer to this can he get?

Let’s hear what you thought of tonight’s episode!


About Us | Advertise with us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use
Get This Theme


All content is Copyright © 2005-2009 b5media. All rights reserved.